The Great Jerky Showdown: Homemade vs. Store-Bought Beef Jerky

The Great Jerky Showdown: Homemade vs. Store-Bought Beef Jerky

Beef jerky has come a long way from being a survival food to a popular snack enjoyed by many. Whether you're a jerky connoisseur or a casual snacker, the choice between homemade and store-bought beef jerky is a decision that can significantly impact your jerky experience. In this article, we'll explore the nuances of both options, weighing the pros and cons to help you decide which route is best for your taste buds and lifestyle.

Flavor Profile: Homemade Creativity vs. Commercial Consistency

Homemade Beef Jerky: One of the most significant advantages of making jerky at home is the freedom to experiment with flavors. Homemade recipes allow you to tailor the marinade and seasoning to your liking, offering a personalized touch that caters to your taste preferences. Whether you prefer sweet, spicy, or savory, the possibilities are endless.

Store-Bought Beef Jerky: Commercially available jerky often adheres to a consistent flavor profile. While this can be comforting for those who enjoy a reliable taste, it may lack the unique and diverse flavor combinations that homemade jerky enthusiasts can achieve. However, some high-quality brands offer a wide range of flavors to cater to different preferences.

Ingredients and Preservatives: Natural vs. Commercial Stabilizers

Homemade Beef Jerky: One of the main attractions of making jerky at home is the ability to control the quality of ingredients. Homemade recipes typically involve fresh, high-quality cuts of beef without the need for artificial preservatives. This can be especially appealing for individuals conscious of additives and preservatives in their diet.

Store-Bought Beef Jerky: Commercially produced jerky often includes preservatives and additives to extend its shelf life. While this ensures a longer-lasting product, it may not be as appealing to those seeking a more natural and minimally processed snack. However, some brands prioritize using high-quality, natural ingredients, offering a compromise between convenience and nutritional value.

Texture and Tenderness: DIY Precision vs. Mass Production Uniformity

Homemade Beef Jerky: Crafting jerky at home allows you to control the thickness of the slices and the overall texture of the finished product. Some may prefer a chewier jerky, while others lean towards a more tender bite. Homemade jerky recipes enable you to tailor the texture to your liking, resulting in a customized snack experience.

Store-Bought Beef Jerky: Commercially produced jerky often adheres to a standardized texture to meet mass production requirements. While this ensures consistency, it may not cater to individual preferences for tenderness or chewiness. However, some brands offer a variety of textures to appeal to a broader audience.

Cost and Convenience: DIY Effort vs. Ready-Made Accessibility

Homemade Beef Jerky: Making jerky at home requires an initial investment in a dehydrator or other equipment, as well as time spent in preparation and waiting for the drying process. While the cost per pound of homemade jerky may be lower, the upfront investment and time commitment should be considered.

Store-Bought Beef Jerky: Commercially available jerky is undeniably convenient. It's readily accessible in most grocery stores and requires no preparation on your part. However, the cost per pound is often higher than making jerky at home, reflecting the convenience factor.


Choosing between homemade and store-bought beef jerky is a matter of personal taste. If you savor creating a personalized, preservative-free snack with a unique flavor, homemade jerky is your go-to. However, if you prioritize convenience, consistency, and a broad flavor selection, store-bought jerky might be more your speed.

Why not have the best of both worlds? Explore crafting homemade jerky when time allows, and keep a stash of your favorite store-bought options for those busy days. And for an added twist, consider enrolling in an Amazon beef jerky subscription for a convenient, flavorful experience delivered to your doorstep. Enjoy the delicious journey, no matter your chosen path!

Back to blog